Workshop:

Traceability Routes for Magnetic Measurements

Date: February 29, 2024
Location:
Torino, Italy
Sala Vallauri, at the INRIM historical building in corso Massimo d'Azeglio 42, 10125 Torino

Click here for remote participation.
ID of the meeting: 390 979 605 651
pass code: iC5JEo

Hotels in the area

Invited speakers
Frank Wiekhorst, PTB Berlin
Pavel Ripka, University of Prague
Sibylle Sievers, PTB Braunschweig
Michael Ortner, Silicon Austria Labs
Werner Bergholz, ISC International Standards Consulting Plamen Stanislavov Stamenov, Trinity College Dublin

Participating in the workshop is free, but registration is required:

Register Here

for both in-person and on-line attendance.

Workshop Schedule here

Michael Ortner, Silicon Austria Labs

Simulating magnetic sensor systems

Abstract:

Magnetic position sensor systems infer the relative position and orientation between a magnetic field sensor and a permanent magnet from the sensor output, that is proportional to the magnetic field generated by the magnet at the position of the sensor. Such sensor systems are widely used in industrial applications due to their excellent properties that include robustness, high resolutions, potential for miniaturization, and high level of cost-effectiveness. Unfortunately, the interplay between magnet, sensor and environment is complex, so that each sensor system requires its own design. What is unfortunate for the manufacturer is fortunate for magnetic system simulation professionals like myself :). In this talk I will discuss magnetic system simulation methods, their potential, possibilities, and limits.

Biography

Michael Ortner is research unit head of Magnetic Microsystem Technologies at Silicon Austria Labs. He has a PhD in theoretical physics and has worked for more than 10 years in applied research on computational magnetism and magnetic position system design with multiple academic and industrial partners.

Sibylle Sievers, PTB Braunschweig

Spatially resolved quantitative magnetic field measurements

Abstract

Macroscopic magnetic field measurements are traceable to primary quantum standards by means of nuclear magnetic resonance, and calibration chains to industry are established. Quantitative spatially resolved magnetic field measurements on micrometer length scales and below are more complex, especially because the spatially varying field distribution is averaged over the finite volume of the field probe. Nonetheless, industry needs standardized and reproducible high-resolution field measurements for quality control in areas like manufacturing of magnetic scales or magnetic storage media.

The European metrology project NanoMag and the thereon based Support for Impact project qMOIF addressed this problem and established traceability routes for highly spatially resolved magnetic field measurements. The NanoMag and the qMOIF project advanced and standardized two complementary measurement techniques that allow to cover the length scale range from the cm to the nm scale, namely magneto optical indicator film magnetometry (MOIF) and quantitative magnetic force microscopy (qMFM). For both techniques, calibration approaches were developed that allow a quantitative field analysis based on the systems output signal. For qMFM, a 50 nm spatial resolution could be validated by an international round robin comparison.

A first international standard for nanomagnetic field measurements covering qMFM was developed and published by IEC TC 113 - Nanotechnologies for electrotechnical products and systems. A second standard for MOIF is under development and will be published within the qMOIF project. Both techniques as well as the respective calibration approaches and applications will be discussed.

The projects (EMPIR 20SIP04 qMOIF and 15SIB06 NanoMag) have received funding from the EMPIR programme co-financed by the Participating States and from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme.

Biography

SS coordinates the EMPIR support for Impact project qMOIF.  She received the Diploma degree in physics and the Ph.D. degree from the University of Göttingen, Göttingen, Germany, in 1994 and 1999, respectively. Since 2004, she has been a scientist with the Department of Semiconductor Physics and Magnetism, Physikalisch-Technische Bundesanstalt, Brunswick, Germany. Since 2022 she heads the “Nanomagnetism” working group. Her current research interests are in the field of quantitative magnetic field imaging.

Pavel Ripka, University of Prague

Applications of magnetic sensors

Abstract

Magnetic field sensors are used in geophysics, in space research and for defense applications. We will concentrate on new advances in sub-pT fluxgate sensors, compare them with other magnetic sensors and describe methods for their calibration and testing. Contactless current transducers are based on magnetic sensors. Modern applications such as smart grids and electromobility require higher precision, robustness, and suppression of external fields. The transducers should be compact and cheap. New designs and materials are employed. Magnetic position and speed sensors are robust and reliable. We will show new types of sensors based on eddy currents and magnetic sensor arrays.

 

 

Biography

PR has a degree in Electrotechnical Engineering from the Czech Technical University, and is professor since 2022. His current research interests include sensors, mainly magnetic, electronic instrumentation in magnetic measurements, fluxgate magnetometers. He is editor and co-author of 4 books (+3 Czech textbooks) and more than 200 published scientific and technical papers. He is author or 6 Czech and 3 international patents. Often invited to the most important international conferences on magnetism, he has been coordinator of several projects and won several awards.

Frank Wiekhorst, PTB Berlin

Reference magnetization measurements to characterize magnetic nanoparticles employed in biomedical applications

Abstract:

Magnetic nanoparticles (MNP) play an important role in biomedical and industrial applications. The economic impact of MNP based biomedical products of European companies alone amounts so far to more than 2 billion € per year. A main application of biofunctionalized MNP is the magnetic separation of DNA, viruses, or other biological targets from biomedical samples by magnetic forces. This creates a demand for a quality control of the main magnetic characteristics of MNP.

While MNP act on a nanoscopic or microscopic length scales, the only viable measurement route for industrial applications is the determination of the field induced magnetic moment of macroscopic MNP samples. Detailed models of the distribution of MNP sizes, magnetic moments and characteristic anisotropy energies are thus employed for the interpretation of the results.

In comparison to bulk materials, the typical net induced magnetic moment of MNP samples in biomedical applications is several orders of magnitude smaller and lies in the same range as the measurement uncertainties. This has severe consequences for the measurement procedure.

We discuss how the traceability of magnetic moment measurements using a commercial magnetometer device can be established by use of reference materials for magnetic moment and magnetic susceptibility as they are provided by NIST. In a carefully designed measurement procedure, the magnetic contributions of the sample holder, the sample container, the suspension medium and other compartments of the MNP sample are determined separately. Furthermore, the influence of sample geometry, sample inhomogeneity and field induced changes in the MNP sample are considered. Finally, the uncertainty budget of liquid MNP sample measurements is outlined that becomes far more complex than that for bulk magnetic materials. Consequently, a reliable and metrologically sound procedure for MNP characterization by magnetization measurements is possible.

Biography

Dr. rer. nat. Frank Wiekhorst was born in 1969 in Wilster, after his study of physics, diploma thesis and PhD at University of Hamburg, he first made a short excursion into marine science. Since 2004 he has been working at PTB in many third party funded projects focusing on measurement techniques for magnetic nanoparticles to be used in biomedical applications. In 2015 he became head of the newly established PTB working group “Metrology for Magnetic Nanoparticles” with presently 10 scientists working in the areas of characterization, quantification, imaging, and standardization of magnetic nanoparticles. For this, a broad infrastructure of established measurement techniques is maintained to determine physical and structural properties of the many magnetic nanoparticle systems that are used in biomedical applications. One focus of his work lies in the development and improvement of imaging modalities that are specifically detecting magnetic nanoparticles such as Magnetorelaxometry Imaging and Magnetic Particle Imaging. These activities are intended to provide a better understanding of the physical and physiological behavior of magnetic nanoparticles to propel their safe and effective biomedical application.

Werner Bergholz, ISC International Standards Consulting

Industrial and Technical Benefits of the MOIF-Technology & -Standardization

Abstract:

In many industries, the utilization of magnetic sensors has been key to important technical improvements. One of the most prominent examples are rotation rate sensors in the automotive industry. Naturally, important quality parameters for such sensors are e.g. their linearity and the standard deviation of the size of the elements of those magnetic gauges. This is particularly true if the intended novel application requires significant improvements of the spatial / rotational resolution.

In principle, the necessary parameter checks on the finished product could be done via high precision methods such as Magnetic Force Microscopy. However, the measurement process is far too slow and prohibitively expensive. Magnetic Optical Indicator Film (MOIF) techniques are an interesting alternative. The methods are by its very nature “parallel” techniques as opposed to the “serial” Magnetic Force Microscopy, i.e. the high throughput, low cost and the possibility of automatic evaluation. Therefore, MOIF is ideally suited for quality control of mass produced magnetic gauges, while the moderately lower spatial resolution compared to Magnetic Force Microscopy is not relevant for most applications.

Furthermore, requirements regarding repeatability and reproducibility are mandatory in many quality management standards, such as IATF 16949 for the automotive industry or similar quality management standards in other quality- and safety-sensitive industries such as aviation or medical technology. Therefore, the development of international standards for the MOIF technology is indispensable to support those industries in the fulfilment of the actual quality requirements for measurement methods laid out in ISO 17005 for laboratories.

In conclusion it is stated that the MOIF example is a good example how standards facilitate the translation of research results into tangible technological and economic advantages.

Biography

1978

Graduation in semiconductor physics, Göttingen University (D)

1978 – 1985

Post graduate research in Göttingen, Aarhus (DK) and Oxford (UK)

1985 – 2002

Siemens Semiconductor Group / Infineon Technologies, last position Quality Director of the Munich Chip factory

2002 – 2015

Professor of Electrical Engineering at Jacobs University Bremen, retirement 2015

2015 - present

Co-founder & partner of International Standards Consulting (ISC) GmbH & Co. KG

Plamen Stanislavov Stamenov, Trinity College Dublin

Systematic Uncertainties in Magnetic Moment Metrology using Second Order

Abstract:

Modern magnetic moment measurements are typically conducted in open magnetic circuit, using commercial, SQUID-amplified, superconducting second-order gradiometer-based magnetometers. These, as of the nature of spatial frequency spectrum of the point-spread function, tend to exacerbate experimental uncertainties, related to sample shape, size, orientation, spatial position, for anything but the most compact and rigidly mounted samples. More and more often, it does become necessary to evaluate the integral moment and magnetisation of extended samples, which are comparable to (and in some cases  bigger than) the gradiometer's base distance or a spatially extending radially far away from the nominal measurement (translation or vibration) axis. Under these circumstances, the systematic uncertainties, primarily in scale-factor, can grow to completely unacceptable levels (> 50 %). Spatially inhomogeneous magnetisation distributions, which are often generated when mounting a large variety of chemical or biological samples which are an even bigger challenge for magnetic moment metrology of this type.

Here we present the essential signal processing that is relevant to the magnetometry problem, give notes on useful approaches to the modelling of the samples and the measurement geometry and demonstrate a number of practical approaches to acquisition (measurement strategies), that allow for the measurement of extended and inhomogeneous samples, and the correct evaluation of the systematic uncertainties. Examples are given of applications using the two most popular commercial systems, the MPMS XL5 and the MPMS SQUID-VSM, both by Quantum Design, San Diego, CA, USA. All algorithms and strategies presented are applicable to any other first or second-order inductive gradiometer, with little to no modifications.

Biography:

Dr. Stamenov’s research interests are focused on the general area of magnetism and spin electronics. He is involved in projects on magnetic tunnel junctions and sensors, oxide magnetic materials, high-frequency magnetics and magnetotransport, applied magnetism, and in particular, materials and measurement techniques for spintronics – the new electronics based on the spin of the electron.

 

Topics covered include: the unexpected magnetism of systems without magnetic ions, and dilute magnetic semiconductors, where the work has been widely recognized and well-cited; more recent work on close-to-antiferromagnetic, zero-moment-half-metals that is already beginning to attract a lot of attention; less fashionable topics include Fermi-surface studies in semimetals and oxides; and the development of unique measurement equipment and novel methodologies. The area of dilute magnetic semiconductors and so-called d0-systems was active 2004 – 2010. The main contribution here has been the discovery and characterisation of the conditions under which certain oxide systems, such as HfO2 and SnO2, exhibit ferromagnetic-like responses – related to doping, atomic defects and nano-/meso-structure. The work has attracted widespread interest of material scientists, chemists and magneticians. The realisation that macroscopic room-temperature magnetic behaviour can have its underpinning not only in localized magnetic moments linked by exchange interactions, but also in defect states, organized with the help of conduction electrons or via second-order-polarisation-effects has had a profound effect on the magnetism community.

 

A more recent focus of the Magnetism and Spin Electronics group at TCD, since about 2010, has been the design and study of systems where there is simultaneously net spin-compensation and high conduction electron spin-polarisation, such as intermetallic alloys in the Mn-Ga family. The prospects of pushing magnetism to these higher frequency bands, together with the purely scientific curiosity as to the interaction of spin-polarised currents with two opposing, chemically inequivalent magnetic sublattices is already attracting the interest of magneticians, resonance specialists, material scientists and inorganic chemists. There are great opportunities here for both novel science, and a transformational breakthrough based on ultra-high-frequency chip-based communications, that could shape the future of ‘big data’ My work on electronic structure characterisation of novel materials has shifted focus from semimetals, such as Highly Oriented Pyrolytic Graphite and bundled carbon nanowires, to the semimagnetic semiconductors ZnO:Co and SnO2, and to ‘bad’ hole-dominated magnetic metals – SrRuO3. This activity is ongoing; gaps in the understanding of the particular materials are filled. Publications in this area are ‘slow-growers’ in terms of citation. Work on the development of methodologies and instrumentation covers magnetometry, Andreev reflection spectrometry, scanning probe techniques and highly-parallel depth-profiling Mössbauer spectroscopy. Dr. Stamenov is a member of the IEEE, the APS, the EMS and the Mag. Soc. Tech. Com and JEMS advisory committee.